Look Away!: A History of the Confederate States of America | 
enlarge | Author: William C. Davis Publisher: Free Press Category: Book
List Price: $35.00 Buy Used: $0.45 You Save: $34.55 (99%)
New (13) Used (55) Collectible (2) from $0.45
Rating: 29 reviews Sales Rank: 332208
Media: Hardcover Number Of Items: 1 Pages: 512 Shipping Weight (lbs): 1.7 Dimensions (in): 9.6 x 6.5 x 1.5
ISBN: 0684865858 Dewey Decimal Number: 973.713 EAN: 9780684865850 ASIN: 0684865858
Publication Date: April 2, 2002 Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
| |
| Also Available In:
|
| Similar Items:
|
| Editorial Reviews:
Amazon.com Review The military history of the Civil War is well known. The political history of the era, and especially of the South, is less documented, a gap that William Davis's Look Away! admirably addresses. Although the rhetoric of secession was democratic, invoking the ideals of the American Revolution and its classical forebears, Southern politics was directed by members of a small, self-serving aristocracy. And though the Confederate government advanced what then and now might be thought to be radical proposals (for one, that the postal service had to be self-supporting within two years of its founding), it was intolerant of dissent; the South's leaders, Davis writes, even barred a constitutional provision "recognizing the right of a state to secede." The natural result, Davis shows, was widespread resistance, including the development of a peace movement and of political groups loyal to the old Union. At the end of the war, Davis writes, "Confederate democracy had gone and would not be seen again--but the oligarchies had survived." Davis's study affords a new view on the Civil War, and it makes a fine addition to the overflowing library devoted to that crisis. --Gregory McNamee
Product Description
William C. Davis, one of America's best Civil War historians, here offers a definitive portrait of the Confederacy unlike any that has come before. Drawing on decades of writing and research among an unprecedented number of archives, Look Away! tells the story of the Confederate States of America not simply as a military saga (although it is that), but rather as a full portrait of a society and incipient nation. The first history of the Confederacy in decades, the culmination of a great scholar's career, Look Away! combines politics, economics, and social history to set a new standard for its subject. Previous histories have focused on familiar commanders such as Robert E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson, but Davis's canvas is much broader. From firebrand politicians like Robert Barnwell Rhett and William L. Yancey, who pushed for secession long before the public supported it; to Dr. Samuel Cartwright, who persuaded many Southerners of the natural inferiority of their slaves; to the women of Richmond, who rioted over bread shortages in 1863, Davis presents a rich new face of the Confederate nation. He recounts familiar stories of battles won and lost, but also little-known economic stories of a desperate government that socialized the salt industry, home-front stories of the rangers and marauders who preyed on their fellow Confederates, and an account of the steady breakdown of law, culminating in near anarchy in some states. Never has the Confederacy been so vividly brought to life as a full society, riven with political and economic conflicts beneath its more loudly publicized military battles. Davis's astonishingly thorough primary research has ranged across the 800-odd newspapers that were in operation during the war, but also across the personal papers of over a hundred Southern leaders and ordinary citizens. He quotes from letters and diaries throughout the narrative, revealing the Confederacy through the words of the Confederates themselves. Like any society, especially in the early stages of nation-building and the devastating stages of warfare, the Confederacy was not one thing but many things to many people. One thing, however, was shared by all: the belief that the South offered a necessary evolution of American democracy. Look Away! offers a dramatic and definitive account of one of America's most searing episodes.
|
| Customer Reviews: Read 24 more reviews...
A fictional indulging of historical myths January 17, 2008 5 out of 8 found this review helpful
For the past fourteen years I have been an ardent and passionate student of the Civil War. I've read dozens of memoirs, biographies, and accounts and have visited every major battlefield in America as well as many of the lesser known ones. I have belonged to two Civil War history organizations and published several writings on the period. Look Away by William C Davis includes none of the facts and truth behind the causes of the Civil War or the causes of secession. His accounts are based on myths fabricated by modern ideas and outlook over one hundred and forty years after the fact. He does not use any material from the accounts or memoirs written by the founders of Southern secession or the Southern Confederacy. Though he got many of the dates, names, and numbers correct, his story, description, and study of them is incorrect. This book does not offer the unique, truthful, or radical glimpse behind the true history of the Confederacy but is rather another very common and stereotypical retelling of the works from other revisionists-revisionists who do not go back in time and record what was written and saved for us to understand now. I do not recommend this reading for anyone wishing to learn about the Southern Confederacy. I instead recommend that you read President Jefferson Davis' historical volume about the birth, life, and fall of the Confederacy titled the Rise and Fall of the Confederate Government. It is legit for the man was not only there with the Confederacy but he had also led it. It also includes thousands of sources and quotes from the period and the period leading to it.
Political history of the C. S. A. July 28, 2007 Well known historian of the Civil War, William Davis, has written a nicely done political history of the Confederate States of America. While, as the author notes (page ix), "The campaigns and battles are here," the main thrust of the book is (page x) ". . .seeks to present a comprehensive view of everything else that went into making the Confederate national experience. . . ."
There is a useful discussion early on of the nature of the Confederate Constitution. My own sense is that this could have been developed better, placing that document in a larger context. Nonetheless, one comes away from the discussion with a reasonable view of the nature of that document--and with an understanding of the importance of slavery for the south.
There is good exposition of the variety of internecine conflicts among the leaders of the Confederacy. President Jefferson Davis' prickly personality scarcely helped out here.
Davis also does a serviceable job of discussing the political economy of the south, from its economic base to the challenges facing its economy as the Civil War unfolded.
All in all, a useful book.
Incomplete, anecdotal, disorganized and inferior. July 23, 2006 3 out of 6 found this review helpful
William C. Davis has done his research; unfortunately, in this case he hasn't balanced it with good organization. The book reads not as a single history or analysis of the Confederacy as a civil government or a nation, but as a series of disjointed essays on different aspects of Confederate life- slavery, civil rights, Unionism, state's rights, the opposition figures in Confederate politics, the economy and the infrastructure. Some of these essays are, by themselves, intriguing- "Cotton Communism, Whiskey Welfare and Salt Socialism" is required reading for any neo-Southron who believes the Confederacy a libertarian ideal. Unfortunately, far too much of the book gives heavy weight to the negatives of the Confederate experiment- hypocrisy, oligarchy, disunion, bickering, inferior industrial strength and disloyalty- and virtually none to the positives.
The unifying premise of the book is that democracy in the Confederacy was doomed, even without the war, because it was crafted and controlled by a slave oligarchy to defend its own interests at the expense of all else. Unfortunately, the book does nothing to prove this. Indeed, we read again and again examples of how the Confederate government and the state governments within it protected freedom and democracy for whites on paper, but failed to protect it in reality... not because the framework was unjust, but because the Confederacy simply did not have the strength to both fight the Union and keep order on the home front. Failure after failure is traced directly to the weakness of Confederate manpower, Confederate industry and Confederate infrastructure... but at the end of each chapter, without support, we are asked to believe that the failures of the Confederacy were due solely to the structure of the system as crafted by the wealthy slaveholding elite.
Davis writes superior history when he sticks to relating historical facts. In these essays he draws conclusions and tries to support them, and the result in an extremely inferior book.
Bland overview of CSA April 28, 2006 0 out of 3 found this review helpful
Davis has done better. Although a thematic, rather than chronological, approach can work in general histories like this, it doesn't work here. There's a lot of jumping around and a lack of coherency at times. Also, Davis used 1/4th of the book just to get to Lincoln's First Inagural. Davis wrote a good history of the origins of the Confederacy, so I don't see why we need 100 pages of detail on that here.
I give it two stars because there's always something to learn from a fine researcher. This one was a big disappointment, though.
Nothing new January 18, 2006 2 out of 4 found this review helpful
On the plus side, Davis is a very good writer and his books are always highly readable. This book is also a good political history of the CSA, although it often focuses too much on certain individuals. The reason I give this book just two stars is because while Davis would have you believe that his book is a new look at the Confederacy, this is really just a regurgitation of Emory Thomas' The Confederate Nation. Davis' book may be more mass market friendly and less academic than Thomas', but Davis' book makes all the same points Thomas' book made back in 1979. Both are worth reading, but know that Davis is not breaking any new ground and I'd say Thomas' work is the better of the two.
|
|
|