Data Modeling Theory and Practice | 
 enlarge | Author: Graeme Simsion
Publisher: Technics Publications, LLC
Category: Book
List Price: $58.95
Buy New: $36.10
You Save: $22.85 (39%)
New (19) Used (3) from $36.10
Rating:  3 reviews
Sales Rank: 518437
Media: Perfect Paperback
Number Of Items: 1
Pages: 416
Shipping Weight (lbs): 1.7
Dimensions (in): 9.9 x 7 x 1.2
ISBN: 0977140016
Dewey Decimal Number: 005.73
EAN: 9780977140015
ASIN: 0977140016
Publication Date: March 15, 2007
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Shipping: Expedited shipping available
Shipping: International shipping available
Condition: Next business day shipping. Please allow 5-10 business days for arrival. 100% Money Back Guarantee.
| |
| Similar Items:
|
| Editorial Reviews:
Product Description
DATA MODELING THEORY AND PRACTICE is for practitioners and academics who have learned the conventions and rules of data modeling and are looking for a deeper understanding of the discipline. The coverage of theory includes a detailed review of the extensive literature on data modeling and logical database design, referencing nearly 500 publications, with a strong focus on their relevance to practice. The practice component incorporates the largest-ever study of data modeling practitioners, involving over 450 participants in interviews, surveys and data modeling tasks. The results challenge many longstanding held assumptions about data modeling and will be of interest to academics and practitioners alike. Graeme Simsion brings to the book the practical perspective and intellectual clarity that have made his Data Modeling Essentials a classic in the field. He begins with a question about the nature of data modeling (design or description), and uses it to illuminate such issues as the definition of data modeling, its philosophical underpinnings, inputs and deliverables, the necessary behaviors and skills, the role of creativity, product diversity, quality measures, personal styles, and the differences between experts and novices. Data Modeling Theory and Practice is essential reading for anyone involved in data modeling practice, research, or teaching.
|
| Customer Reviews:
 A valuable contribution to the field of data modeling revealing many useful insights August 14, 2007
3 out of 3 found this review helpful
After spending 25 years practicing, lecturing, writing about, studying, and teaching data modeling, I was thrilled to discover new insights and gain more clarity in this field due to Dr. Simsion's diligent work that is shared in his latest book, "Data Modeling Theory and Practice". Like many data modelers, I have strong views on this subject and it was interesting to be able to see the broad range of opinions, experiences, and even to be able to see some of the diverse models produced in the research contained with this book. One of my views is that the more perspectives you can see, the greater the clarity. So, regardless of your views on data modeling, if you are interested in furthering your understanding of the discipline of data modeling, then I would highly recommend reading this material as I give my "two thumbs way up" to this revolutionary book.
A must read for both practitioners and academics June 11, 2007
3 out of 3 found this review helpful
I found this book to be a valuable sequel to the beginner and intermediate modeling texts, such as Data Modeling Made Simple and Graeme's first book, Data Modeling Essentials. This book provides a great mix of both academic and practitioner approaches to data modeling. I have been an analyst and modeler for a number of years and found the side by side comparisons of experts' believes and approaches to be fascinating. While reading this book, I found myself asking questions on my own beliefs and approaches to modeling, and this really helps improve the consistency of my modeling decisions. This is an intermediate to advanced modeling text that is extremely well-written and provides valuable insight into how we do data modeling.
 The message we need to hear April 9, 2007
8 out of 8 found this review helpful
To me, this book's value is a bit like children being warned not to accept lollies from strangers; it's a pity we even have to give such warnings, but it's absolutely essential we do. I wish to congratulate Simsion for bravely tackling a subject of much heated controversy, and in a manner that obviously reflects both a solid practitioner's hard-won lessons, but that is supported by rigorous academic research.
So what's this important message? Simply that data modelling is a creative exercise, where multiple "solutions" may be generated, each with relative merits. The importance lies in practitioners consciously and deliberately generating alternatives. Without this open-minded view, I have personally witnessed heated debates where one modeller defends his/her model because they know it can be made to work, and therefore assumes anything different must be "wrong". But even more significantly, modellers may stop looking as soon as one "workable" model is tabled, and hence miss out on alternatives that may prove beneficial in a given business context.
And why is it even controversial? Apparently, some academics teach data modelling that way. Maybe because it's easier for them to have one "correct" answer to a problem so marking assignments is easier? Or maybe that was what they were taught, and any students who pass through their ranks and end up teaching without encountering real-world modelling may perpetuate?
One warning, though. This book is not the first text to be read by those interested in data modelling. I would recommend Simsion & Witt's "Data Modelling Essentials for such people, followed by one of many excellent books on "patterns". David Hay got the patterns topic going in the data modelling community, and Len Silverston's two volume series has taken it much further. And the object-oriented community also has contributions to make on patterns.
A minor criticism - Simsion largely dismisses the use of the Unified Modeling Language's class modelling notation, in part arguing that "Class diagrams are intended to represent data structures which might be directly implemented using an object-oriented database" and goes on to correctly note the struggle of such databases to gain significant database market share that their vendors initially might have predicted. I would simply comment that there is a difference between using a subset of the class modelling syntax to represent what is truly a data model, as compared to using class modelling notation to represent classes which, in some cases, may never have "persistence" i.e. may never have their data values stored in a database of any kind. And even if class diagram notation is used (some might say misused?) just to represent a data model, I have seen this approach used quite effectively. So on this point, it looks like Simsion and I have slightly different views. But at the very heart of his book, he encourages open debate on alternative views, with the understanding that all views may have something to contribute.
So let's thank Simsion for offering his views, and encouraging others to offer theirs. Well done, it's a great reference book (probably not easy reading for those not exposed to research styles - but don't let that put you off), and one that hopefully bridges the gap between academics and practitioners, and gives the practitioners "permission" to be creative as most know is the way to generate alternative solutions for consideration.
|
|
|
